The new “Three Kingdoms” made Liang Gonggeng “Xiangyang” Nanyang netizens quit
This matter has been debated for thousands of years. Emperor Jiajing was once disturbed, but it is still inconclusive
Shenbojun, a senior expert of the Three Kingdoms, said: the dispute over land cultivation is completely caused by the changes of administrative divisions
Quarrel and quarrel for a thousand years. A new “Three Kingdoms” has ignited the war of words between Nanyang and Xiangfan.
Where is the “land where Zhugeliang worked”?
In the new “Three Kingdoms”, it was set in Xiangfan.
Nanyang netizens immediately set off a wave of Crusades, claiming that 10000 netizens signed to boycott the new Three Kingdoms.
A thousand years of debate may not have an absolute result.
Experts said that once the academic community has a conclusion, the investment return of the party who has been “capped” may be significantly reduced.
Want to unite thousands of people and refuse to watch the new Three Kingdoms
Just as the new “Three Kingdoms” was popular, yesterday, some netizens made bricks on the Internet, saying that they would unite 10000 netizens to refuse to watch the TV series. What’s the secret?
“Love of the wind” posted that “the minister should be clothed in cloth, and work hard in Nanyang” was what wise sage Zhugeliang said in his previous “starting a career”. At the beginning, it was pointed out that work hard is Nanyang.
Moreover, Emperor Shizong of the Ming Dynasty once appointed Nanyang WoLonggang as a place to worship Zhugeliang.
“However, the new commercial and entertainment series the Three Kingdoms, created by director Gaoxixi, blatantly adopted the flawed ‘Xiangyang theory’ to make Zhugeliang’s bow and plough into Longzhong, Xiangfan, Hubei Province. This added a particularly ugly code to all kinds of farces that joked about history and trampled on traditional culture.”
“Love of the wind” proposed to Zhugeliang’s descendants that they should jointly boycott the new pseudo historical drama “Three Kingdoms” and invite netizens from various websites to carry out a signing campaign in the name of “Nanyang netizens” to “refuse to see the new Three Kingdoms and return me to WoLonggang”.
Disgust with the Three Kingdoms
Originated from “where to cultivate”
Yesterday, the reporter contacted the “love of wind”.
“The purpose of posting is to call on Nanyang netizens to refuse to read the new Three Kingdoms.” According to the theory of romantic love, his dislike of the new Three Kingdoms stems from “where Zhugeliang worked”.
In the 32nd episode of the new TV series the Three Kingdoms, Xu Shu told Liu Bei, “30 miles outside Xiangyang City, there is a mountain named Longzhong, where a genius lives.”.
Some netizens said that when Liu Bei invited Zhugeliang out of the mountain in episode 33, he mentioned WoLonggang several times, which was not unrelated to Nanyang.
Love of the wind means that there are many WoLonggang in China, not only in Nanyang, but also in Chengdu and Xiangfan.
“I am very disappointed with the relevant departments.” According to fengzhilian, the textbook has been changed. The annotation of “Longzhong” in the junior middle school Chinese textbook is: “the name of the mountain is now in Xiangfan, Hubei Province”, and the annotation of “Nanyang” in the “minister, cloth, and plough in Nanyang” in the “teacher’s guide” is: “Nanyang, the name of the county, is now in Xiangyang, Hubei Province”.
He insisted that Zhugeliang’s cultivated land was in Nanyang, but now it was “robbed” by other places, which made him very unhappy.
He said that he even wanted to build a WoLonggang website to publicize Nanyang’s culture of the Three Kingdoms. “It’s OK to do general websites, but I haven’t done professional websites. I’m just a junior high school culture.”
Eryuehe: Xiangfan belonged to Nanyang County in the Eastern Han Dynasty. This statement is a guess
In the view of Eryuehe, a famous writer from Nanyang, it is normal to have protests on the Internet.
“Now that there are neither new discoveries nor new cultural relics unearthed, it is categorically said that Zhugeliang cultivated land in Xiangyang. From an academic point of view, this view is too fragile!”
In order to support the “Nanyang theory”, Eryuehe also produced several sets of evidence. One of the most important evidences is that Zhugeliang’s “starting out as a teacher” says: “the minister should be clothed in cloth and work hard in Nanyang.”. “As for some people who said that Xiangfan belonged to Nanyang Prefecture at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, I don’t agree with this view. It’s all speculation!”
“Of course, I don’t doubt that Zhugeliang has been to Xiangyang or has a villa in Xiangyang, but his main activity area is Nanyang.”
However, Eryuehe also persuaded netizens not to pay too much attention to Xiangyang in the new Three Kingdoms. “TV plays are works of literature and art. They are equivalent to novels we read. There is no need to be too serious.”
[step on one foot]
Shenbojun: the struggle for land is actually the change of administrative division
Shenbojun is the director of Sichuan Three Kingdoms culture research institute. He has studied the Three Kingdoms for 30 years and is one of the most authoritative experts in China. He believed that Zhugeliang’s dispute over cultivated land was actually a problem of the change of administrative divisions.
“At the end of the Han Dynasty, Longzhong was administratively subordinate to Deng County, Nanyang County, but geographically closer to Xiangyang City, only 20 miles away.” Shenbojun said that many places in Hebei Province are close to Beijing, but they do not belong to Beijing.
The administrative subordination of Longzhong was different in ancient and modern times: in the Eastern Han Dynasty, it belonged to Deng County, Nanyang County; Today it belongs to Xiangfan City, Hubei Province. There are countless changes in the subordination relationship in history.
In addition, in Nanyang County in the Eastern Han Dynasty, “Longzhong” was a small place name. It was located in the border area between Nanyang County and Nanyang County. Administratively, it was under the jurisdiction of Deng County, Nanyang County (now North of Xiangfan, Hubei Province), and the specific geographical location was 20 miles west of Xiangyang County, Nanyang County (now 13 kilometers west of Xiangfan City, Hubei Province).
Due to the changes of historical geography and the concept of administrative region, some people in later generations confused Nanyang Prefecture in the Eastern Han Dynasty with Nanyang Prefecture after the Yuan Dynasty (today’s Nanyang, Henan).
High risk should also be considered in the dispute over the hometown of celebrities
Peiyu, director of Tianjin historical society and a young scholar, has paid close attention to the dispute over the hometown of celebrities for many years.
He said that the dispute over hometown is particularly prominent in Henan, Shandong, Hebei, Anhui, Hubei and other provinces. The main reason is that these provinces have established the development strategy of “tourism as a province”.
Peiyu said that Nanyang City clearly proposed to “start the planning and construction of WoLonggang cultural tourism industry cluster” in the 2010 government work report. According to the plan, it is estimated that the comprehensive income of cultural tourism in the cluster area will reach 415million yuan in 2012; In 2015, it will reach 1.435 billion yuan.
The Three Kingdoms Cultural Tourism Zone, led by Longzhong, is a priority tourism development area and project in Xiangfan during the “Eleventh Five Year Plan” period, with a total area of 209 square kilometers. By 2010, it is expected to receive 1-1.5 million tourists and earn 800million-1billion yuan.
However, the development of the economy of the hometown is not “indisputable”. Peiyu reminded governments at all levels that although this is a high return, it has high risks. Once the academic conclusion is reached, the investment return of relevant projects may be significantly reduced by the party who is “capped”.
[history of striving for land]
In the Ming Dynasty, the emperor was disturbed by a lawsuit
About Zhugeliang’s cultivated land, Nanyang and Xiangyang have been arguing for thousands of years, and there is no final conclusion so far.
During the Jiajing period of the Ming Dynasty, there was a great deal of incense on WoLonggang, and it was at the same time that Zhugeliang was engaged in a fierce debate over farmland. Xiangyang and Nanyang said that the two factions held their own views and did not give in to each other. The lawsuit went to the Imperial Academy and even shocked emperor Shizong of the Ming Dynasty.
In the light years of the Qing Dynasty, gujiaheng, a native of Yichang, Hubei Province, came to Nanyang to become the prefect. At that time, Xiangyang people and Nanyang people fought for Zhugeliang. In a hurry, the prefect wrote a couplet – “the heart is in the imperial court, no matter what the Lord is first, then the LORD; why distinguish Xiangyang Nanyang from the world”, which was placed in the Wu Hou shrine.
In 1990, China Post issued the second group of special stamps of the romance of the Three Kingdoms. One of them was “three visits to the moulu”, which touched the nerves of Xiangfan and Nanyang. Finally, the national stamp issuing department had to let the two places hold their own launch ceremonies.
In 2003, the junior middle school Chinese textbook of the people’s Education Edition re included Longzhong Dui, which added: “Longzhong, the name of the mountain, is now in Xiangfan, Hubei Province.”. “Nanyang” is annotated as “Nanyang, the county name, is now in the Xiangyang area of Hubei Province” in the “graduation form”. This strongly stimulated the whole Nanyang, and the “textbook gate” broke out.
On june8,2008, a column of CCTV broadcast an urban advertisement in Xiangfan, Hubei Province – “ZHUGE bows to farmland, Xiangfan City with mountains and rivers”, which also aroused the protest of Nanyang people. It is an “advertising gate”.